Why Women Should Prioritize Strength Training Over Cardio
In the realm of fitness, cardio has long dominated the conversation for women. However, emerging research and expert insights continue to highlight the unmatched benefits of strength training for women’s health, longevity, and overall well-being. Dr. Stacy Sims, a leading expert in female physiology and training, extensively discusses why women need to shift their focus from endless cardio sessions to strength and resistance training.
The Science Behind Strength Training for Women
Women experience unique physiological changes throughout their lives ranging from hormonal fluctuations during the menstrual cycle to the complex transitions of perimenopause and menopause. Strength training is crucial in helping women adapt to these changes and maintain optimal health.
Unlike cardio, which can often contribute to muscle breakdown, strength training provides the necessary stimulus to preserve and build lean mass, which is essential as women age.
The Role of Strength Training in Hormonal Balance
One of the biggest misconceptions in women’s fitness is that lifting weights will lead to a bulky physique. In reality, strength training plays a pivotal role in managing hormonal changes, particularly in perimenopause and menopause, where women face a decline in estrogen and progesterone. This decline leads to a loss of muscle mass, reduced bone density, and an increased tendency to store visceral fat.
Stacy Sims explains:
"Estrogen is responsible for muscle protein synthesis, strength, and power in women. Progesterone and estrogen are responsible for bone growth and density. We can’t rely on our hormones for this anymore. We need an external stress." (1:47:00)
By engaging in regular resistance training, women can combat these physiological shifts, maintaining strong bones, lean muscle, and a higher metabolic rate.
Strength Training for Fat Loss and Metabolism
Many women turn to cardio as their primary method for fat loss. While cardio burns calories during the workout, it does little to improve long-term metabolic function. In contrast, strength training creates an “afterburn” effect, where the body continues to burn calories even after the session ends.
Sims highlights:
"If we rely on long, slow, or moderate-intensity cardio, it’s not going to create the kind of stress we need to invoke change... We need to do proper high-intensity work or true resistance training to create a stress that is high enough to have the brain say ‘Hey, we need to store more glucose in the muscle and burn more fat.’" (1:47:19)
Women who prioritize strength training over excessive cardio sessions will experience greater fat loss, improved body composition, and better energy levels.
Preventing Age-Related Muscle and Bone Loss
One of the most significant risks women face as they age is osteoporosis and sarcopenia (age-related muscle loss). Since estrogen plays a key role in maintaining bone density, its decline during menopause puts women at higher risk for fractures and bone-related diseases.
"If we start losing bone density and become osteopenic or osteoporotic, we are at risk of fractures and mobility issues. Resistance training - especially power-based training - is the best way to stimulate bone growth and maintain skeletal strength." (1:25:00)
Lifting weights stimulates bone-forming cells and increases bone mineral density, reducing the risk of osteoporosis and ensuring long-term mobility and independence.
How Women Should Strength Train
To reap the benefits of strength training, women should focus on progressive overload, meaning they should gradually increase resistance over time. Sims recommends a power based resistance training approach, with exercises that emphasize compound movements such as:
Squats
Deadlifts
Lunges
Pull-ups
Presses
Additionally, incorporating plyometrics (jump training) can further enhance bone density and muscular power.
"We’re not going to the gym for an hour and a half every day. We’re looking at doing short, sharp, high-intensity cardio or power-based resistance training three times a week." (1:48:04)
Final Thoughts
Strength training is not just about aesthetics - it’s about longevity, metabolic health, and resilience. While cardio has its place, women should prioritize lifting weights to ensure they maintain muscle mass, bone density, and metabolic efficiency throughout their lives. The key takeaway - Drop the fear of bulking up and start training for lifelong strength and health.
-
The Science of Strength Training for Women (YouTube, uploaded by The Diary Of A CEO, February 2024). Available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=It5_C6AF1pk